Geoffrey is actually killed from inside the a cycling crash within the 1186 and Constance hitched (2) Ranulph de Blundeville, 4 th Earl from Chester, into the step three rd February 1188, when you look at the a married relationship create by the Queen Henry 11. Which marriage deteriorated and you will Ranulph imprisoned Constance in 1196. Rebellions was started all over Brittany on her and you can Ranulph put-out their particular for the 1198. Back into Brittany, Constance had their own relationships annulled and later in the 1198, she grabbed People de- Tours given that their particular ‘second’ spouse.

Constance passed away old 40, (perhaps out of leprosy, perhaps following childbirth in order to dual girls) with the 5 th September 1201 on Nantes

Although this wasn’t an effective consanguineous relationship but certainly one of affinity, any earliest-training dating might have rendered matrimony anywhere between Constance and you will any of John’s brothers impossible instead an excellent dispensation –– and that given the party’s review might have was required to are from the brand new pope themselves

The concept that Constance had an event which have John adopting the loss of Geoffrey and you may in advance of John’s relationship to help you Isabella regarding Gloucester into the 1189, hence she are mother in order to Joanna is quite controversial and you may enjoys provoked far dialogue in this genealogical circles.

That feedback out-of good genealogist states one to ‘the latest diary ‘The new Plantagenet Connection’ has actually penned an ahnentafel from E Plantagenet, spouse away from Henry V11, gives Joanna’s mother’s label as the Constance (possibly misnamed Clemence?), Duchess off Brittany. This is the Constance who had been John’s sis-in-rules! As a result of the better-recognized animosity between John and you can Constance and her very own attempts to force their unique young man Arthur’s interests in terms of the brand new throne out-of England are concerned (and we all know the way disastrously one to ended up!), I truly find the suggested dating a tiny hard to consume. The Constance one to background illustrates will not hit myself due to the fact on whom John can potentially coerce with the sleep.’

‘ A concept who does choose Joanna’s mommy since the Constance fails to account for an incredibly critical part of canon law. Who does mean that certain shade of number need to definitely have come down to all of us, if this in it the latest ask for they, the new deliberations, or the genuine dispensation in itself. In so far as i in the morning alert, little of the kind exists.’

By the merely which have sex having John, let alone bearing him a baby, Constance would have oriented a first-education dating away from affinity along with John’s sisters –– and additionally John’s aunt Geoffrey

My advice for what it is worthy of, would be the fact got Constance started the mother off Joanna she’d definitely has actually delivered their own up inside her house and her label might be also known as Constance’s almost every other children of the Geoffrey (Eleanor, Fair Housemaid off Brittany, Matilda/Maud of Brittany and you can Arthur).

Agatha came into this world in the 1168 in Chartley Palace, Staffordshire. It’s well known that she try a domme off John and several members of the family woods give her, even though unmarried, since mom regarding Joanna. Very genealogists not believe that it is just conjecture you to definitely the woman is Joanna’s mom given brightwomen.net tutkia sivuston that zero research otherwise facts exist to demonstrate it.

One to supply appear to considering is Sir William Dugdale, regarding Baronage regarding The united kingdomt (1675-6). He says their resource to be Dr David Howell’s ‘Reputation for Wales’ (1584). Powell’s tasks are an enlarged release regarding H Lloyd’s translation out of ‘New Historie off Cambria’ by several th century Saint Caradoc of Llancarfan. Yet another origin, ‘Magna Carta Barons’ by the Charles Browning, copyright laws 1969 and brands Agatha de- Ferrers, daughter regarding Robert de- Ferrers, fourth Earl from derby, given that Joanna’s mommy.

Regardless of if she can not be totally overlooked just like the a candidate to own mommy away from Joanna, certainly there would be particular trace away from their within the good chronicle and other historic source, in the event that she got actually come mom of the wife off the fresh Prince off Northern Wales.